Showing posts with label school. Show all posts
Showing posts with label school. Show all posts

Monday, October 22, 2007

Scotus Congress

Currently reading:
Itinerarium Mentis in Deum
   by St. Bonaventure

I am now back from the Scotus Congress which was at St. Bonaventure's. It was a bit of a change in pace. At Trinity, I'm pretty much the resident scholastic. At the congress, though, I felt like an infant in the world of medieval studies. It was cool though to meet some other people with similar interests and to get some tips on how to proceed. The papers which I heard seemed to fall into three camps: the ones which were great, though I couldn't quite catch everything; the ones which were decent, but mostly rehash of stuff I know; and the ones which were pretty much a waste of time (either they weren't very good, or I couldn't follow them at all, or both).

I've regained some motivation, but the usual question of breadth vs. depth still plagues me. I want to learn everything, but I want to learn it all well. To really do medieval philosophy would require steeping in it for a good amount of time, it seems. So to do comparative work with, say, Madhyamaka and Yogacara Buddhism would be fascinating, but I couldn't really get all of the good stuff out of either then.

Also, if I were to go along a more purely medievalist route, would I want to do more with philosophy and theology, in which case I would continue with some training in modern philosophy in which case I could work with the thinkers as relevant to today, or would I continue in a more historical vein, understanding the context better and perhaps unearthing some less-studied (but nonetheless astute) thinker? Practical calculations also seem to play a role. I think I would prefer going with a straight-up medieval studies degree more (at least during the studies, I don't know about the subsequent career path), as I could dabble in other areas more easily (bored with philosophy? let's look at the historical context. Bored with history? What literature could be influenced by these thinkers?). However, it would be a fair bit easier to get a philosophy job (not that that would be a guarantee itself). In addition, there is the issue of where I could benefit the community the best. With my talents & interests and the current historical circumstances of American intellectual culture, would I better serve the community by bringing the thought of these guys into contemporary discussion (building conceptual bridges), or by working on critical editions, translations, and the like (building practical bridges)?

Sunday, May 06, 2007

Reflections on Academics

Thinking through last semester as to why it was so stressful, I think one of the things is that I feel like I have to effectively study for three different reasons, each with a substantial amount of stuff to get through.

  1. Short Term: I need to get through school and get my degree. Further, I need good grades to get into a good doctoral program. At the same time, classes seem to tie into the other two areas of study at a depressingly low rate; often, it feels like I simply need to get through a class in order to jump another hoop. Better classes provide atlases for the topic in case I want to return in my own time, but I still feel overwhelmed at the end of the class by the subject matter and not prepared to deal with it.
  2. Long Term: The research which follows more-or-less stable interests and which gives me an area of specialization. I need something which I can write on, and afterwards feel like I actually knew about what I was writing. Also, I need an area of interest which reminds me why I am in philosophy and theology. Sometimes I can tie this into class papers, but when classes are all across the board or are intro classes (or both, like this semester), I'm not quite sure how to pull this off.
  3. Edifying: I have specific questions at specfic times, and I want to be able to study more about them. These questions change around, so this isn't a long-term study project, but it is something which would help me immensely if I had time for it. Unfortunately, the other two areas are more practical and I feel more pressured into studying them so that I can eventually get a job.

The long and short of it is, I don't have time to do all three at any level of quality (especially when making time for my wife and working a draining job with unstable hours), but I need all three for one reason or another. Trying to do all three often leads to burnout, which leads to doing none of them. Further, I don't always know who to trust on given issues, especially when it comes to reading theology; there's always another argument, always another exegesis, and quite frankly, I am less than impressed by much evangelical writing (not that I'm typically any more impressed by liberal, or postmodern, or non-evangelical Reformed writing). So I don't feel like I can know anything about an issue without spending tons of time and energy which I don't have researching it. I am at the point where I am afraid to start researching more than a single topic at a time; given the real world, I feel pulled apart in all different directions, and in the end going in none (or in all, grisly results included).

Anyone have any tips for getting out of the mire?